Watkins Bay
Menu
All insightsEconomic impact

Young firms and job creation: why new companies matter more than small ones

It is often said that small businesses create most jobs. The research tells a more precise story: it is young firms, not small ones, that drive net job creation. Here is what the evidence shows.

LRLilly Ryan Associate Analyst4 min read

Key points

  1. Kauffman Foundation research found that US firms less than five years old account for nearly all net job creation.
  2. Firm age is a better predictor of job creation than firm size.
  3. Most young firms stay small or fail; a small share of high-growth firms create a large share of jobs.
  4. Australia's Productivity Commission has linked slower business dynamism to weak productivity growth.

Politicians often describe small business as the engine of job creation. It is a comforting idea and partly true, but the research points to a more precise driver. When economists separate firms by age as well as size, it is young firms that stand out.

What the US research found

The Kauffman Foundation, a US research organisation focused on entrepreneurship, worked with special tabulations of US Census Bureau data to study job creation by firm age. In a 2010 paper, researchers Dane Stangler and Paul Kedrosky summarised the finding plainly: young firms, those less than five years old, account for nearly all net job creation in the United States.

The important word is “net”. Older firms create many jobs, but they also shed many as they restructure, automate or close. Once gains and losses are netted out, the contribution of young firms is what keeps overall job growth positive.

A later Kauffman report, published in 2022, added nuance. It found wide variation in the number of jobs young firms create. Many new firms never hire, and others create only modest employment. A small share experiences very high growth and creates a significant number of jobs. The same report noted evidence that job creation by new firms in the United States has declined over several decades.

Why age matters more than size

Small firms include a huge range of businesses: a long-established family accounting practice, a corner store, a two-person software startup. Most small businesses do not intend to grow large, and that is entirely reasonable. Size alone therefore says little about future employment.

Age captures something different. New firms are where experimentation happens. Some fail quickly, which is costly for the people involved but frees up resources for others. Some grow and become large employers. US Bureau of Labor Statistics data show the churn: about one in five new establishments closes in its first year, and roughly half survive five years.

What this means for Australia

Australia’s research points in a similar direction, alongside concern about declining dynamism. The Productivity Commission has reported that Australia’s labour productivity growth averaged just 1.1% a year over the decade to 2020, the slowest rate in 60 years. Monash University economist Stephen King, who worked on that inquiry, noted that rates of firm entry and exit declined between 2005-06 and 2012-13, and that more recent increases in entry were mainly among non-employing businesses.

That matters because a healthy flow of new employing firms is one of the ways new ideas and better practices spread through an economy.

Comparing regions

In Europe, a frequent concern is that new firms are created but too few scale. In Asia, the picture varies widely: some economies have very high rates of new firm formation, while others are actively trying to increase it. Japan, for example, launched a five-year plan in 2022 that aims to multiply startup activity. The common thread is that policy makers increasingly look at the birth and growth of firms, not just the number of small businesses.

Implications for founders and policy makers

For founders, the research is a reminder that the contribution of a startup extends beyond its own balance sheet. Each employee trained, supplier engaged and customer served adds to the wider economy.

For policy makers, the evidence supports measures that make it easier to start, grow and, when necessary, close a business. Programs aimed only at small business by size may miss the firms most likely to create new jobs.

Frequently asked questions

Does this mean small businesses do not matter?

No. Small businesses employ millions of people and provide essential services. The research simply shows that new jobs on a net basis come disproportionately from young firms, many of which are small at the start.

Are startups and young firms the same thing?

Not exactly. All startups are young firms, but most young firms are not high-growth startups. The term “startup” usually refers to a young company designed to scale quickly.

Is the same pattern seen outside the United States?

Many developed economies show similar patterns, though the strength varies with labour markets, regulation and access to capital.

References

General information only. This article reflects the author’s views at the time of writing. It does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs, and it is not financial, legal or tax advice or a recommendation to invest. Figures are from the sources named and may change. See our terms of use.

A new insight every Monday.

Startups, venture capital, economic impact and the trends behind them. Get Adam’s weekly notes by email through Start Up Growth Hacking, or follow by RSS.