Watkins Bay
Menu
All insightsEconomic impact

Australia's productivity puzzle and the role of new firms

Australia's productivity growth has been the slowest in decades, and the rate at which firms enter and exit has declined. Here is what the research says about the link between new firms and productivity.

YRYani Ryan Associate Analyst4 min read

Key points

  1. The Productivity Commission found Australia's productivity growth averaged 1.1% a year over the decade to 2020, the slowest in 60 years.
  2. Indicators of business dynamism, including firm entry and exit, declined in the 2000s and early 2010s.
  3. Recent increases in firm entry have mainly been among non-employing businesses.
  4. New, growing firms help spread new ideas and pressure incumbents to improve.

Productivity is the quiet engine of living standards. When workers and businesses produce more with the same inputs, wages can rise without fuelling inflation. Australia’s productivity record over the past two decades has been weak, and economists have spent considerable effort trying to explain why. One part of the story is the flow of new firms.

The size of the problem

In its 2023 five-yearly productivity inquiry, Advancing Prosperity, the Productivity Commission found that Australia’s labour productivity growth averaged just 1.1% a year over the decade to 2020, the slowest rate in 60 years. Australia is not alone; many developed economies have experienced a similar slowdown since the mid-2000s.

What business dynamism means

Economists use the term “business dynamism” to describe the churn of firms and workers: businesses starting, growing, shrinking and closing, and people moving between jobs. In a dynamic economy, resources flow from less productive to more productive uses. New firms bring new ideas and challenge incumbents. Exits release capital and people for better opportunities.

The Productivity Commission told a parliamentary inquiry in 2023 that several aggregate indicators suggest competition and dynamism in Australia may be declining. Monash University economist Stephen King, who worked on the inquiry, has summarised the evidence: rates of firm entry and exit declined between 2005-06 and 2012-13, job switching slowed and business concentration increased.

King adds an important caveat. More recent increases in firm entry have mainly been among non-employing businesses, such as sole traders and contractors, rather than firms that hire. And he argues that declining dynamism, while undesirable, is not sufficient on its own to explain the productivity slowdown.

Why new firms matter

Research from the United States helps explain why policy makers care. The Kauffman Foundation found that young firms account for nearly all net job creation in the US. New entrants are also where many new technologies and business models first appear.

When fewer firms enter, incumbents face less pressure to improve, and good ideas spread more slowly. When fewer firms exit, capital and talent can stay locked in less productive businesses.

How Australia compares

The slowdown is shared across rich economies, but the responses differ. The United States has a deep venture capital market that funds new firms at scale. Europe has focused on making it easier for startups to scale across a fragmented single market. Several Asian economies, including Japan and Singapore, have adopted explicit national plans to increase startup formation and investment.

Australia has policy levers of its own, including the Research and Development Tax Incentive, tax incentives for early-stage investors and government co-investment vehicles. The question is whether these, combined with regulatory reform, are enough to lift the rate at which new employing firms enter and grow.

What would help

The research points to several directions:

  • Lower barriers to entry: simpler licensing, faster approvals and clearer regulation for new business models.
  • Access to growth capital: a healthy pipeline from angel and seed funding to later-stage investment.
  • Easier exits: insolvency processes that allow failed ventures to close efficiently and founders to try again.
  • Labour mobility: settings that make it easier for workers to move to growing firms.

None of these is a silver bullet. The Productivity Commission has emphasised that a broad microeconomic reform agenda is needed.

Measuring dynamism is harder than it sounds

One reason the debate continues is that dynamism is difficult to measure well. Counts of new businesses mix sole traders with firms that will employ hundreds. Exit statistics can rise because of healthy competition or because of economic stress. Job switching can fall because workers are content, because the population is ageing or because barriers to mobility have risen. Researchers therefore look at several indicators together, including entry and exit rates, the share of employment in young firms, job reallocation and the growth of high-performing firms. When most of these point in the same direction, as they did in Australia for much of the 2000s and early 2010s, the case for concern is stronger.

Frequently asked questions

Is declining dynamism the main cause of slow productivity?

Researchers disagree. It is one contributing factor, but others include slower technology diffusion, weaker investment and changes in the industry mix.

Do startups make a measurable difference to national productivity?

Individually, rarely. Collectively, the flow of new firms is one mechanism by which productivity improves over time, through competition and the spread of new practices.

What can founders do about national productivity?

Building a well-run, growing company is itself a contribution. Founders can also take part in policy consultations, which often seek evidence from businesses about barriers to entry and growth.

References

General information only. This article reflects the author’s views at the time of writing. It does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs, and it is not financial, legal or tax advice or a recommendation to invest. Figures are from the sources named and may change. See our terms of use.

A new insight every Monday.

Startups, venture capital, economic impact and the trends behind them. Get Adam’s weekly notes by email through Start Up Growth Hacking, or follow by RSS.