Watkins Bay
Menu
All insightsVenture capital

How venture capitalists actually make decisions: what the research says

A landmark survey of 885 venture capitalists shows what investors weigh most, where deals come from and how firms decide. Here is what the research says and what it means for founders.

YRYani Ryan Associate Analyst4 min read

Key points

  1. A survey of 885 VCs at 681 firms found that investors weigh the management team more heavily than product or technology.
  2. VCs rate deal selection as the most important driver of value, ahead of sourcing and post-investment support.
  3. About 30% of deals are self-generated by investors and only about 10% come from unsolicited founder approaches.
  4. Venture capital suits a small minority of companies: fewer than one quarter of one per cent of US firms receive it.

Founders often describe venture capital decisions as a black box. A pitch goes in, a yes or no comes out, and the reasoning in between can feel opaque. Academic research has done a good deal to open that box.

The most cited study is “How Do Venture Capitalists Make Decisions?” by Paul Gompers of Harvard Business School, Will Gornall of the University of British Columbia, Steven Kaplan of the University of Chicago and Ilya Strebulaev of Stanford. Published in the Journal of Financial Economics in 2020, it surveyed 885 institutional venture capitalists at 681 firms.

The team matters most

The headline finding is that VCs rate the management team as more important than business characteristics such as the product or technology. They also attribute the eventual success or failure of their investments more to the team than to the business.

That does not mean product and market are ignored. Investors still assess market size, competition, business model and traction. But when they look back on what went right or wrong, they tend to point to people. For founders, this explains why investors spend so much time on founder backgrounds, how co-founders work together and how they respond to hard questions.

Selection beats sourcing and support

The survey asked VCs which of three activities contributes most to value creation: finding deals, choosing among them, or helping companies after investing. Respondents rated deal selection as the most important of the three.

This matches what the authors reported in a 2021 Harvard Business Review article based on the same research: for every deal a VC firm closes, it considers about 101 opportunities. Most of the work is saying no.

Where deals come from

The research also shows that a large share of deals come through networks. Almost 30% of deals are proactively generated by the investors themselves, and only about 10% arrive as unsolicited approaches from company management. The rest come through referrals from other investors, colleagues and the investor’s broader network.

For founders, the implication is practical. A warm introduction from someone the investor trusts is far more likely to be read than a cold email. That is not a judgement on the quality of cold approaches; it is a reflection of how busy firms filter a very large number of opportunities.

How decisions are made inside firms

The study found meaningful differences across stage, industry and geography. Early-stage investors put more weight on the team because there is less business data to analyse. Later-stage investors rely more on financial metrics and comparables. Most firms use some form of partnership or investment committee vote, though practices vary on whether unanimous support is required.

The research also reminds us how rare venture funding is. The authors note that fewer than one quarter of one per cent of US companies receive venture financing. Venture capital is designed for a narrow set of businesses that can grow very large, very quickly.

How this applies outside the United States

The survey focused mainly on US investors, so care is needed in applying it elsewhere. In Australia, the venture market is smaller and more concentrated, which can make networks and reputations even more important. In Europe, government-backed investors play a larger role in the market than in the United States. In parts of Asia, corporate and family investors are especially active. The core logic, that investors back people they trust to execute in markets that can grow large, travels well.

Frequently asked questions

Does this mean the idea does not matter?

The idea matters, but investors know ideas change. They are judging whether this team can find and execute on a large opportunity, even if the first version of the idea turns out to be wrong.

Is a cold email ever worth sending?

It can be, especially to investors who publicly invite approaches in your sector. A short, specific note with evidence of traction works better than a long pitch. Warm introductions still tend to get more attention.

Do these findings hold in Australia?

The study did not focus on Australia, so the exact figures may differ. However, local investors describe similar priorities, and the importance of networks is often greater in a smaller market.

References

General information only. This article reflects the author’s views at the time of writing. It does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs, and it is not financial, legal or tax advice or a recommendation to invest. Figures are from the sources named and may change. See our terms of use.

A new insight every Monday.

Startups, venture capital, economic impact and the trends behind them. Get Adam’s weekly notes by email through Start Up Growth Hacking, or follow by RSS.