Watkins Bay
Menu
All insightsStartups

Your first ten hires will shape the company more than your first ten customers

Early hires set the culture, the pace and the standard for everyone who follows. Here is how founders can hire well when money is tight and every seat counts.

ARAdam Ryan Managing Partner3 min read

Key points

  1. Early hires set the culture and standards that later hires copy.
  2. Hire for the next 18 months of the company, not the next 18 days.
  3. Be explicit about values before you need them in a hard decision.
  4. Equity and vesting should be agreed and documented from the first hire.

Founders spend a lot of time thinking about their first customers. They should spend at least as much thinking about their first hires.

Your first ten people do more than get work done. They decide, mostly without anyone saying so, what good looks like in your company: how fast decisions get made, how honest the conversations are, and what happens when something goes wrong. Everyone who joins later learns from them.

Hire for where you are going

The most common early mistake is hiring for today’s fire. A founder is buried in support tickets, so they hire someone to answer tickets. Six months later the company needs someone who can design a support function, and the person in the seat can’t grow into it.

A better question is: what will this role need to look like in 18 months, and can this person get there? You won’t always get it right. Asking the question changes who you look for.

Values are a hiring tool

Every founder says they care about culture. Few write down what they mean before they need it. By then, the first hard decision has already been made, and that decision becomes the culture.

Write your values as decisions, not slogans. “We tell customers the bad news first” is a value you can hire for and hold people to. “Integrity” on its own is not.

Culture is not what you say in the all-hands. It is what your first ten people do when nobody is watching.

Look for range, then depth

Early on, people wear several hats. A great early hire is comfortable with ambiguity, learns fast and is willing to do work outside their title. As the company grows, you will need specialists. Knowing which phase you are in helps you avoid hiring a specialist too early, or keeping a generalist in a role that has outgrown them.

Get the paperwork right from day one

Equity is one of the most powerful tools a startup has to attract people. It is also one of the easiest to mess up.

  • Document every equity promise at the time it is made.
  • Use vesting, typically over several years with a cliff, so equity is earned over time.
  • Assign intellectual property to the company in every employment and contractor agreement.
  • Keep the cap table current so it matches your share register and your option plan.

Investors check all of this in due diligence. Fixing it later is slow and expensive, and sometimes impossible.

Hire slowly, act quickly

The old advice still holds. Take the time to hire well: speak to references, test real work, and involve the people who will work alongside the new hire. And when it is clear a hire is not working, act quickly and fairly. In a team of ten, one wrong seat is ten per cent of the company.

Every company in the Watkins Bay portfolio has faced these decisions. The ones that got their early team right found everything else easier.

General information only. This article reflects the author’s views at the time of writing. It does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs, and it is not financial, legal or tax advice or a recommendation to invest. Figures are from the sources named and may change. See our terms of use.

A new insight every Monday.

Startups, venture capital, economic impact and the trends behind them. Get Adam’s weekly notes by email through Start Up Growth Hacking, or follow by RSS.