Watkins Bay
Menu
All insightsStartups

Advisory boards or formal boards: what founders need and when

Advisory boards and formal boards of directors serve very different purposes. Here is how they differ, when each makes sense and how founders can set them up well.

LRLilly Ryan Associate Analyst3 min read

Key points

  1. A formal board has legal authority and duties; an advisory board offers informal guidance without legal duties.
  2. Advisory boards suit early stages when specific expertise is needed without formality.
  3. Formal boards become important with institutional capital and outside shareholders.
  4. Define roles clearly, use written agreements and vest equity for both advisers and directors.

As startups grow, founders often seek outside experience. Two common structures are an advisory board and a formal board of directors. They are frequently confused, but they have very different roles, responsibilities and legal consequences.

The formal board of directors

A company’s board of directors is its governing body. Directors are appointed under the company’s constitution and corporate law, and they carry legal duties. In Australia, those include duties to act with care and diligence, in good faith in the best interests of the company and for a proper purpose, to avoid improper use of position or information and to prevent insolvent trading. Similar duties exist in other jurisdictions.

The board approves major decisions, such as issuing shares, raising capital, appointing and removing the chief executive and approving budgets. In venture-backed companies, lead investors often take board seats, and independent directors may be added as the company grows.

The advisory board

An advisory board is informal. It has no legal authority, and its members do not carry directors’ duties. Advisers offer expertise, introductions and feedback, usually meeting less frequently and in less structured ways than a board.

Advisers are often compensated with a small amount of equity, typically through options that vest over time.

Key differences

  • Authority: the board makes binding decisions; advisers make recommendations.
  • Legal duties: directors have statutory duties and potential personal liability; advisers do not.
  • Accountability: directors are accountable to shareholders; advisers are accountable only under their agreements.
  • Commitment: board roles typically require regular meetings and preparation; advisory roles are usually lighter.

Why founders change roles over time

Founder roles change as companies grow. Harvard Business School professor Noam Wasserman reported in a 2008 Harvard Business Review article that half of the founders in his research were no longer chief executive by the time their ventures were three years old. Strong boards help companies navigate those transitions, and advisers can support founders as their roles evolve.

When each makes sense

An advisory board can help early, before a formal board is needed, when founders want specific expertise, such as regulatory knowledge, industry relationships or technical depth, without the formality of directorship.

A formal board becomes important when the company raises institutional capital, has outside shareholders whose interests must be protected or reaches a size where governance and oversight are essential. Research by Paul Gompers and colleagues, surveying 885 venture capitalists, found that investors place great weight on the team, and a well-functioning board is part of how investors judge a company’s maturity.

Setting up advisers well

To get value from advisers:

  • Define the role. Be specific about what you want help with and how often you will meet.
  • Use written agreements. Cover equity, vesting, confidentiality and intellectual property.
  • Vest equity over time. Tie equity to ongoing contribution.
  • Review regularly. Advisory needs change; it is fine to end arrangements that no longer fit.

Setting up a board well

For a formal board, aim for a mix of founders, investors and independent directors as the company grows. Hold regular meetings with clear papers circulated in advance. Record decisions in minutes. Bodies such as the Australian Institute of Company Directors offer guidance for new directors.

Regional considerations

Corporate law differs between Australia, the United States, European countries and Asian jurisdictions, but the distinction between directors with legal duties and advisers without them is broadly consistent. Founders should take advice on the rules that apply where their company is incorporated.

Frequently asked questions

Can an adviser become a director later?

Yes. Many companies appoint trusted advisers to the board as governance needs grow, with appropriate agreements and awareness of directors’ duties.

Do advisers need insurance?

Advisers without directorships do not carry directors’ duties, so directors and officers insurance is less relevant, but clear agreements are still important.

How many advisers should a startup have?

Enough to cover key gaps, often two to five. Too many can dilute equity and attention without adding value.

References

General information only. This article reflects the author’s views at the time of writing. It does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs, and it is not financial, legal or tax advice or a recommendation to invest. Figures are from the sources named and may change. See our terms of use.

A new insight every Monday.

Startups, venture capital, economic impact and the trends behind them. Get Adam’s weekly notes by email through Start Up Growth Hacking, or follow by RSS.