Watkins Bay
Menu
All insightsStartups

What I look for in a founding team before the product is ready

Before a product is ready, a founding team is the clearest signal an investor has. Adam Ryan sets out the qualities he looks for in founders at the very earliest stage, and why.

ARAdam Ryan Managing Partner3 min read

Key points

  1. Research on 885 VCs found investors rank the team above product or technology at the early stage.
  2. Speed of learning, deep customer knowledge and skill fit are strong signals before a product exists.
  3. Candour between co-founders, and early agreement on roles and equity, reduces later risk.
  4. The ability to recruit talent, customers and advisers is an early test of leadership.

When there is no product, no revenue and no customers, what are you actually backing? In my experience, the answer is almost always the people. That view is not just mine. When Paul Gompers and colleagues surveyed 885 venture capitalists for research published in the Journal of Financial Economics, investors rated the management team as more important than product or technology, and attributed success or failure more to the team than to the business.

So what makes a strong team before the product is ready? These are the qualities I look for, drawn from building companies myself and backing others.

They learn faster than the market changes

Early-stage companies are learning machines. The first plan is almost always wrong in important ways. What matters is how quickly a team notices and adjusts.

I ask founders what they believed six months ago that they no longer believe. Good teams answer quickly and specifically. They can describe the evidence that changed their mind and what they did differently as a result. Teams that cannot name anything they have unlearned worry me more than teams that have changed direction several times for good reasons.

They know the customer better than I do

By the time we meet, a strong team should know more about its customers than any investor in the room. That means names, workflows, budgets, buying processes and the specific moments when the problem bites. It does not require a finished product. It requires curiosity and legwork.

I am wary when founders talk about a market in the abstract, such as total addressable market figures, without being able to describe a real customer in detail.

The skills fit the first two years

No founding team has every skill. What I look for is a fit between the skills the team has and the problems it will face in the next couple of years. A deep technology company needs technical founders who can build what others cannot. A company selling to large enterprises needs someone who can navigate procurement and long sales cycles. A consumer business needs people who understand distribution and brand.

Gaps are fine if the founders can name them and have a plan to fill them.

They are candid with each other

Co-founder conflict is one of the most common reasons I have seen early companies stall. I pay attention to how founders talk about each other, how they divide responsibilities and how they make decisions when they disagree.

Teams that have already had a hard conversation, about equity, roles or commitment, tend to be more resilient. Agreements made before money and pressure arrive are far easier than those made after.

They can recruit

A founder’s first job beyond the product is to attract others: early employees, advisers, customers and investors. I look for evidence that people want to work with this team. Have they convinced someone talented to join for less money than they could earn elsewhere? Have early customers given them time and data?

Where geography comes in

These qualities apply wherever a company is built, but context changes how they show up. In Australia, teams often need to think globally from day one because the domestic market is small. In the United States, a team can build a large business in one market but faces intense competition for talent. In Europe and Asia, language, regulation and local relationships can be as important as product skills. I look for teams that understand the market they are choosing and the one they may need to grow into.

Frequently asked questions

Do solo founders struggle to raise capital?

It can be harder, because investors worry about key-person risk and workload. Solo founders who build a strong early team, advisers or a board can address many of those concerns.

How important is prior startup experience?

Helpful but not essential. Relevant industry experience, deep customer insight or technical depth can matter as much as having founded a company before.

What is the biggest red flag in a founding team?

Unresolved disagreement about roles, equity or commitment. It rarely improves under the pressure of fundraising and growth.

References

General information only. This article reflects the author’s views at the time of writing. It does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs, and it is not financial, legal or tax advice or a recommendation to invest. Figures are from the sources named and may change. See our terms of use.

A new insight every Monday.

Startups, venture capital, economic impact and the trends behind them. Get Adam’s weekly notes by email through Start Up Growth Hacking, or follow by RSS.